Should Australia become a Republic?
Australia should.....
Side Score: 22
|
Australia should not....
Side Score: 29
|
|
|
|
1
point
1
point
1
point
Even Prince Charles agrees! He said: "It seems to me that it would be a lot easier for everybody if you all had your own completely independent head of state" Side: Australia should.....
1
point
1
point
If it became like the American system, Clive could become the Aussie Donald Trump #$$$ #moneywinselections Side: Australia should.....
1
point
Scroll down to the graph cos it clearly shows that we should become a republic Side: Australia should.....
1
point
0
points
0
points
0
points
0
points
0
points
As the President cannot be a member of the political party, or a MP, there is more emphasis placed on being chosen by merit and not money - unlike the American Model. This is a point of unification for Australian politics, as the President would require support from both sides of politics. Side: Australia should.....
|
5
points
2
points
2
points
The nomination of the President is very confusing. The package suggests that everyone will have a chance to nominate a fellow Australian for the office of President, and these nominations will be considered by a special Nominations Committee made up of representatives "from Australian parliament and all parts of our community". This committee will select a shortlist, from which the Prime Minister and Leader of the Opposition will select one nominee. This seems an unnecessarily political and extensive way to choose a President. A perfectly stable and effective model is to have the people choose the President, as is the case in the US and numerous other countries. This approach to nomination seems like an attempt to cover all bases, making the process as long-winded and difficult as possible and not allowing the people any significant input. Side: Australia should not....
1
point
1
point
1
point
1
point
1
point
The referendum is not just about whether Australia should become a republic, but also the proposed setup of this republic. On this, both the referendum question and accompanying passage are very vague. The proposed model involves a President appointed by the politicians, not the people - who will this person owe allegiance to? Who can they be dismissed by? Will they use their powers more readily than the current Governor-General, who (as dictated by convention) does not use them? Side: Australia should not....
1
point
1
point
1
point
http://www.quickmeme.com/img/36/ Side: Australia should not....
1
point
1
point
1
point
Teaching the history of the British Empire links in with that of the world: for better and for worse, the EMPIRE MADE US WHAT WE ARE, FORMING OUR NATIONAL IDENTITY. A country that does not understand its own history is unlikely to respect that of others. Antony Beever - respected historian Side: Australia should not....
|